Accessing Medical Records to Contest a Will

Accessing Medical Records to Contest a Will

There are a few reasons why a family member may want to access the medical records of a loved one after they’ve died.

This might be to determine whether a medical diagnosis was missed, for example if someone died of cancer, or because you have a potential claim after the person’s death. But there are strict rules around accessing someone’s medical records after death, and it’s not always possible to do so.

Who Can Access Medical Records after Death?

Under the Access to Health Records Act 1990, you can only access someone’s medical records if you’re:

  • The Personal Representative of the person who died (such as the Executor or Administrator of the Estate)
  • Someone who may have a claim as a result of the person’s death (usually a dependent such as a husband, wife, civil partner or child). In this case, you can only access information that is directly related to the claim

If you’re looking to make a claim about the validity of a Will, this is where things can get a little more complex, especially if the Personal Representative is refusing to get involved and help you access the records.

Another issue you might face is that, in England and Wales, a person’s privacy rights to their medical records can be extended even after they die, if they requested it. If this is the case, no one will ever have the legal right to access the medical records of the person who has passed away.

What Challenges Could this Cause?

Even if you’ve got a legitimate reason for wanting or needing to access the medical records, the Access to Health Records Act states that if there’s a note on someone’s medical record saying that they don’t give permission for anyone to access their records after their death, then this has to be respected.

This can cause some challenges for family members wanting to contest a Will by using their loved one’s medical records to show that their Will may be invalid, on the grounds of testamentary capacity.

Testamentary Capacity

Testamentary capacity refers to someone’s mental and legal ability to make a Will. If it can be proven that someone lacked testamentary capacity when making their Will, then the Will is invalid.

If you want to contest a Will because you believe that the person who made it lacked the mental ability to do so, then accessing their medical records is usually a crucial part of supporting your claim with strong evidence.

But what happens if the person who made the Will specified that no one can access their records?

Well this may make a claim a little trickier, as medical records and doctors’ statements are invaluable evidence when it comes to proving a lack of testamentary capacity in making a Will.

Instead, you may have to rely on witness statements from those who knew the person who died, or consider taking legal action to fight for your right to access your loved one’s medical records.

Read more stories

Join over 6,000 wills and probate practitioners – Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our weekly round up every Friday morning. 

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.